A mine can meet local standards and still face challenges that delay and disrupt its operation. New analysis explores how standards and regulations interact with key factors to determine whether a mine can sustain operations.
Even as national regulatory frameworks are becoming more robust, and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) practices proliferate in the mining industry, formal compliance alone does not guarantee a mine’s continuity or stability. A project may meet legal requirements, report favorable sustainability indicators, and attract significant investment, yet still face resistance from local communities.
The necessity of maintaining high standards of practice through the adoption of sustainability frameworks and regulations is not in question. The unresolved issue is understanding which institutional, social, and governance conditions translate compliance on paper into true operational viability. Addressing this issue requires examining how standards and regulations interact with key factors that determine whether a project can sustain operations in practice.
What Is Operational Viability?
Operational viability refers to a project’s ability to sustain operations over time and depends on whether formal requirements, operational practices, and stakeholder expectations can stay aligned.
However, operational viability does not mean preserving business as usual. The concept connects industrial performance to the broader conditions and challenges that determine whether a project can continue operating. It includes a project’s ability to anticipate and manage institutional blockages, social conflict, and breaches of trust before those challenges interrupt operations.
Specifically, operational viability requires the intersection of three dimensions:
- regulatory compliance, which establishes the legal foundation for the country’s mining rules and regulations
- international ESG and sustainability standards, which structure the management of environmental, social, economic, and institutional risks and affect how an exporting country interacts with foreign firms and importing countries
- the social license to operate, which reflects a project’s capacity to build and sustain legitimate, stable relationships with key stakeholders—including those who control local power networks and dynamics on the ground
These dimensions are interdependent. A project may be legally compliant without sufficient local acceptance; it may have ambitious ESG policies that are not fully integrated into daily operations; and it may receive initial stakeholder support without the institutional mechanisms needed to sustain that relationship over time.
Governance Challenges
Governance challenges exist across all dimensions, limiting the ability of projects to achieve operational viability. Below, we discuss four challenges that help explain why adopted formal requirements do not always produce operationally viable projects.
Limited Institutional Capacity to Implement Rules
Adopting a legal framework or international standard is not enough to guarantee effective implementation of the adopted rules. Capable institutions must translate formal obligations into practice by ensuring that those responsible for implementing the adopted rules are monitored and their commitments are enforced over time; under certain conditions, governance arrangements may also need to adapt. The challenge is therefore not the existence of rules, but the government’s capacity to implement them effectively.
This challenge is particularly visible in mechanisms designed to generate local benefits in mining regions. In the Democratic Republic of the Congo, environmental, social, and community-development obligations are already embedded in legal and regulatory frameworks. The difficulty lies in determining the structure of the oversight and commitment mechanisms, such that the adopted rules result in intended outcomes; notably, successful mechanisms hinge on including communities as an essential part of the process.
In this context, local participatory governance has emerged as a mechanism for improving regulatory implementation. Local participatory governance creates a bottom-up system for communities and individuals to be directly involved in policy decisions and implementation. By creating channels for dialogue, monitoring, accountability, and stakeholder engagement, participatory governance can help align formal requirements with local realities and strengthen the institutional conditions that are necessary for sustaining mining operations over time.
However, participatory governance still does require institutional capacity for monitoring compliance. For example, though in the Democratic Republic of the Congo participatory governance provides citizens with the ability to vote on how a percentage of mining revenues are spent, compliance gaps remain due to limited institutional capacity. These compliance gaps have resulted in limited information reaching communities regarding what they were promised and what has been completed, and reporting delays from the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative make timely oversight difficult.
International Agreements Are Unable to Be Implemented Effectively at the Local Level
International agreements can create conditions for responsible critical mineral development that support economic growth and deliver lasting local benefits. However, agreements will be actionable at the project level only if national institutions can lay out clear implementation requirements, both for the project developers and the regulators.
Specifically, implementing internationally negotiated commitments at the individual project level requires addressing several questions: What mechanisms connect project-level commitments to national and local regulatory frameworks? Who monitors implementation? How can different local stakeholders participate in governing the resulting economic and social impacts? Effective coordination between international agreements, national institutions, and project-level governance is therefore essential to ensuring that international commitments are implemented at the project level.
Failure to Align National Sovereignty with Local Participation
During recent sessions of the UN Security Council concerning the full sovereignty of countries over their natural resources, the Democratic Republic of the Congo and other nations emphasized the importance of sovereign control over natural resources. Yet this call for sovereignty was accompanied by a request for stronger international governance arrangements for strategic minerals.
Adopting international governance frameworks does not imply giving up full sovereign control. Nations retain authority over resource governance through their legal frameworks, while international agreements establish broader expectations and conditions that shape how resource development unfolds in practice.
On the other hand, sovereignty should not be understood solely as a matter of centralized authority. The extent to which producing territories and local communities participate in decisionmaking and benefit from resource development also influences the long-term sustainability of extractive projects. Meaningful local inclusion, from decisionmaking to benefit sharing, is therefore both a key dimension of project governance and an expression of national sovereignty.
Governance Fragmentation Can Undermine Implementation
Recent initiatives, discussions, and analyses point to a common trend: the proliferation of governance instruments, from international standards to corporate commitments. While this trend reflects a genuine and growing desire to make mineral value chains more responsible and sustainable, this proliferation can create a risk of regulatory overload, and an implementation gap between formal commitments and what occurs in practice, if the various instruments are not sufficiently coordinated or aligned.
To that end, the Regional Economic Integration Framework (REIF) of the Great Lakes region in the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Rwanda calls for the harmonization of mining policies and commits to fighting the illicit trafficking of conflict minerals and promoting sustainable regional value chains. However, the REIF does not take steps to help these governments manage the regulatory overload and implementation gaps caused by the abundance of mining policies.
This lack of implementation assistance from REIF is a challenge, because greater consistency and coordination among diverse policies does not by itself ensure effective implementation or sustainable project outcomes. Here, too, institutional capacity is the binding constraint: governments and companies must be able to translate standards, regulations, and agreements into practices that are applied, monitored, and adapted over time. Where that capacity is limited, the implementation gap can persist and standards are more likely to fail—particularly without participatory inclusion.
Taken together, these governance challenges show that compliance is not achieved simply by having formal requirements on the books. Rather, compliance requires countries to have the institutional capacity to implement requirements consistently, be able to coordinate across levels of governance, and actively incorporate meaningful community participation. Operational viability therefore rests on whether formal commitments can function coherently in practice.
A Framework for Measuring Project Viability
These implementation and governance challenges point to the need for a broader framework that assesses the conditions that shape a project’s operational viability.
To address this, one of us (Ghislain Kabumba R. Baderha) developed the Integrated Governance and Sustainable Mining Performance Framework (IGSMP) in a study conducted between 2024 and 2026 through a multidisciplinary collaboration involving more than a dozen international experts in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Specifically, the IGSMP includes the three key aspects identified above—regulatory compliance, ESG and sustainability standards, and social license to operate—in one integrated framework to measure the operational viability of projects. The framework provides a quantitative approach to assess each of these dimensions and combines them into a single quantifiable value: an operational viability factor. The operational viability factor essentially allows a government to score whether alignment among these dimensions will translate into sustained project operations over time.
The framework is not another standard added to an already crowded field. Its contribution responds to a criticism raised in the literature: that the proliferation of standards and frameworks adds complexity without necessarily improving outcomes. Rather than replacing existing instruments, the IGSMP offers a common basis for harmonizing instruments and adapting them to specific contexts. In this way, the framework speaks directly to the regulatory overload and implementation gap described earlier, which arise when overlapping instruments are not sufficiently coordinated or aligned. The framework shows how regulations, ESG standards, and community expectations interact, and where that alignment breaks down because governance capacity or community trust is weak. By quantifying these factors, the framework explains why some formally compliant projects sustain operations while others remain vulnerable to disruption, and it gives governments a way to assess the long-term resilience of their mineral projects.
Ultimately, operational viability depends on the effective integration of government capacity, international cooperation, and local participation. By showing where these conditions fall short, the framework points policymakers to the gaps that are most likely to threaten long-term project viability, such that formal commitments can effectively translate into sustainable and lasting operations.